The Brains

Breaking

Friday, May 31, 2013

Is “Kaptan” Really Satisfied With PTI`s Performance?



The Pakistani media kept its focus on the dissolution and re-organizing of the MQM`s Co-ordination Committee and KTC (Karachi Tanzeemi Committee) from its Quaid Mr. Altaf Hussain immediately after the 11 May, 2013. Analysts expressed their views on this matter from different angles. Some called it MQM`s internal conflicts; other declared it as the result of the PTI`s emergence as a new competitor in Karachi; while a few considered it as mainly a routine internal re-organization.

In the elections 2013, MQM has almost retained all of its national and provincial seats (except NA-250 and its relevant two Provincial seats PS-112,PS-113 where it partially boycotted the re-polling only in 43 polling stations). Moreover, it also got one additional NA seat (NA-239) and three new PS seats (PS-1, Ps-90 and PS-128). Thus, as per the election results 2013, over all MQM`s performance was good. However, the analysts seem to be ignoring the overall performance of the most important political party PTI in the recent elections. PTI was claiming to bring about a Tsunami for making a clean sweep throughout the country, but it could manage to get only 28 seats in the National Assembly out of 272 that constitutes only 10.29.% showing its very poor performance.

Traditionally, the opposition parties always get the benefit of their position by maligning the government parties on genuine or non-genuine issues in the country. Especially in a country like Pakistan, they have nothing to do except criticizing the government in order to fertilize the political ground for their own government in future. That was exactly what was done in the last five years. As a result, the political ground had become very favorable for all the opposition parties including PML-N, JI, JUI-F and PTI in comparison to PPP, ANP and MQM. Moreover, the threats and the resulting attacks from Taliban on the formal coalition parties had greatly reduced the possibility of their notable success in the election.

In addition to these positive aspects, PTI was having some more benefits in the elections. It was having a previously untested leadership, and had mainly focused the youth and the voters who had kept off the election process for years. Moreover, its zealous election campaign, expensive advertisements and the over whelming presence of PTI supporters on social media had increased the possibilities of its huge success over the others. In this way, of all the opposition parties, PTI was in the best position to cash in on the prevailing scenario and turn it into its victory. But, surprisingly, PTI showed a very low performance in response to the expectations from it. It managed to get only 28 seats in the National Assembly in comparison to its only competitor PML-N which easily got 144. Although PTI leveled the allegation of rigging in the elections, but IK`s demand of recounting only in 25 seats of Punjab indicates the confession of his political defeat there. The results of the PTi`s performance not only surprised several political analysts, but also shocked its supporters.
As per the election commission, the turnout was 55%. The question is, what about the still remaining 45% of the voters who did not cast their votes? Why did they not come out to vote for PTI`s change? Were they still waiting for a new leadership other than Imran Khan? If one take into account all these things, will he/she not raise a big question mark on the performance of PTI? Is the PTI leadership unaware of this very crucial aspect?

It is fact that PTI has got the second highest votes in the country, yet securing only 28 national assembly seats was not according to its clearly set objective. The question is, why does PTI leadership look to be relatively content on its performance as is apparent from the statements of its leaders who are declaring it an outstanding performance? Should IK not critically assess the performance of its officer bearers and workers in the most crucial “match”, i.e., elections 2013? When, MQM`s Quaid, despite its quite satisfactory performance in the elections, can seriously decides to re-organize its top cadre of the leadership, what is PTI waiting for? Imran Khan has played all of its cards, what does he have for the new elections now?

If PTI is still contemplating to use the same slogan of change in order to attract the Pakistani public in the future elections, then it would be living in a fool`s paradise as it will have neither the fertilized political ground like 2013 again in future, nor would it remain an untested party anymore. Furthermore, it has formed its government in KPK. Now, it would have to deliver in order to meet the people`s expectations that had gone very high due to the Captain`s claims. When MQM, despite having had neither its own CM nor the ministry of Interior to restore peace especially in Karachi, can be held equally responsible for whatever happened in the country, then how can PTI avoid the responsibility of especially the killings from suicide and drone attacks in KPK? Does the PTI`s “Kaptan” have the answer to this question that will decide his fate as well?


No comments:

Post a Comment